The purpose of this workshop was to engage a diverse group of smart communities’ researchers and practitioners on potential revisions to the S&CC solicitation and future priorities for the program. The report summarizing the discussions and recommendations from the February 2024 S&CC Visioning Workshop is now available. Read the full report here.
The S&CC program at NSF was launched in 2017 to fund research that advances the state of the art in smart communities, with a focus on sociotechnical research that addresses community informed challenges and priorities. With the current solicitation set to expire on April 1, 2024, the program is considering how its mission and goals need to be revised to account for recent advancements in computing, engineering, and the social sciences, along with the evolving state of community needs and priorities. Additionally, several programs have been launched at NSF in recent years (e.g., CIVIC, SAI, ReDDDoT, RITEL) that have overlapping themes with S&CC and NSF seeks to provide greater clarity to the research community on ideas that are appropriate and in-scope for S&CC.
As such, the program is considering the following revisions to its solicitation:
- Increased support for high-risk/high-reward concepts, centered around technological advancements. PI’s will be encouraged to undertake foundational research in computing and engineering that carries significant risk, with proposed outcomes that will be transformative for communities if successful.
- Social and behavioral research on proposals must ask and address questions relevant to its technological goals. Ideas that primarily make contributions to social and behavioral sciences, with minimal technological advancements, will be encouraged to seek funding opportunities with programs such as ReDDDoT, SAI, and RITEL.
- Acknowledging that programs like CIVIC require deep community partnerships and ready-to-pilot concepts, S&CC seeks to support more exploratory research, where ideas are informed by community perspectives, but deep partnerships are not a major requirement. Additionally, the focus on scaling, sustainability, and transferability may need to be adjusted to account for the exploratory nature of the work.
- Proposals scoped for 3-4 years of research, with a maximum budget of $1.5M.
These high-level goals for a program revision are still at the conceptual stage and the outputs of this workshop will inform the NSF as it considers a solicitation revision.
Location and Date
This one-day workshop was held at Vanderbilt University on Tuesday, Feb 27th (one day prior to the 2024 NSF S&CC PI meeting) at the Vanderbilt Community Event Space, 208 24th Ave N, Nashville, TN 37240
Workshop Agenda
8:00 am - 9:00 am | Networking Breakfast Reception/Registration |
9:00 am - 9:15 am | Welcome and Introductions |
9:15 am - 10:00 am | NSF Overview of Proposed Changes to S&CC Comments on the Future of Smart Communities: Dr. Tho Nguyen, Senior Officer on the Computer Science an Telecommunications Board (CSTB), National Academy of Sciences (10 minutes) Open Q&A between workshop attendees and NSF staff (20 minutes) |
10:00 am - 12:00 pm | The Future of Smart Communities
Primary activity will involve backcasting: “Backcasting is a planning method that starts with defining a desirable future and then works backwards to identify the steps or actions that will connect that specified future to the present.” Format will include breakouts to facilitate domain-specific discussions and a report out at the end. |
12:00 pm - 1:00 pm | Lunch Break |
1:00 pm - 3:00 pm | High-Priority Research Areas for Smart Community Futures
|
3:00 pm - 3:30 pm | Community Informed Research in S&CC Discussion on the scope and scale of community engagement for the proposed changes to S&CC |
3:30 pm - 4:30 pm | Proposed Changes to the Budget Discussion on revising the budget to 3-4 years at $1.5M |
4:30 pm - 5:30 pm | Workshop Reflections and Open Q&A |
6:30pm | Post-Workshop Dinner Miel Restaurant (343 53rd Ave N, Nashville, TN 37209) |